Discussion about this post

User's avatar
John Ward's avatar

@Chris Chen I have become a paid subscriber for a variety of reasons. Let me go through some of them.

The first was for exclusive content that appealed to me in some unique way. For example, I subscribed to @John Toma ⚡️ That 80s Dude because he started offering a pdf version of a zine. He does such a great job with formatting it to look like a relic from the 80s and 90s that I wanted to experience it.

At times I have been persuaded to become a paid subscriber because of the value of the pre-paywall content. @Alberto Romero remains the very best example of this. I was a free subscriber to his AI newsletter for around a year before becoming a paid subscriber for the next two. I was on the fence about paying for his newsletter for a long time (simply because I was paying for so many already), but his consistent releases and the quality of his writing convinced me to start paying for his work.

Sometimes I will pay for content as an expression of support. I won’t tag individuals for this one but there are people who are doing good work here that I simply want to encourage.

The real problem that Substack faces now is abundance. There are just too many great newsletters out there. At one point I was subscribed to over forty. I’ve since cut back because I can’t keep up. I have experimented with moving select feeds to an RSS reader to follow them there, but honestly that doesn’t work as well as I’d like. In-app notifications for articles are easy to dismiss. Email offers a persistent artifact that reminds you to read it every time you see it.

I don’t know what the answer to this is and the answer is probably different for every person. I’m heavy into audio because I wear hearing aides and always have access to Bluetooth speakers which makes it convenient to listen to articles, but audio streams aren’t always available. Other people appreciate video. Still others, text.

There really is a reason that attention is the scarecest thing on the internet.

Radhika Parashar's avatar

Welcome, it's so nice to have you here!

I have often subscribed to someone on Substack because of either a piece that delivered extreme value and then I realized that there could be more content behind a paid wall. In the case of Predictive History, I subscribed because there was enough there that I was curious to learn more about it, over time. Sometimes, like in the case of Lenny's Newsletter, I subscribed because there are lots of freebies that you get as a result of the subscription that kind of justify the cost of it. Actually, reading the information is just half of the puzzle. The other half of it is having tools and a guidebook, courtesy of the Substack, to allow me to do more with it.

Really excited to see how this grows. I sincerely hope that the sort of authenticity that's on Substack and the way we were able to connect with one another, that didn't have to do with short-form video content and all the other sort of attention-grabbing ways that other social media platforms have used to create an attention economy, kind of stays off of this. Even the paid models are proven out with some level of genuineness, for lack of a better word.

I say this because I have come across some creators who are like 100% peddling wares and while I may have subscribed to them over time and that time normally is like a day or two, I get slammed with so many emails that it feels like spam and I just have to unsubscribe. I can't imagine what it's like to pay for their content, especially when a lot of it is about maxing Substack and turning it into the next Instagram or the next TikTok or the next sort of attention economy piece. I really hope that this can be a place for people to just sincerely share and create paid followings because of value rather than because of gimmicks.

34 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?